Was Pir Meher 'Ali Shah the Conqueror of Qadian or is that the Crude Vision of his blind followers? This book is a critical review of the pamphlet Fateh-e-Qadian written by a Maulvi Mushtaq Ahmed of Chishti of Norway. His claims of the so-called 'victory' of Pir Meher 'Ali Shah of Golrha against the Promised Messiah^(as), Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian, are exposed in light of documented historical facts. In this book, details of the events that occurred before and after Pir Meher 'Ali Shah's open criticism of the Promised Messiah^(as) are documented. After studying this book, it becomes clear that any claims of the Pir's victor against the Promised Messiah and Mahdi^(as) of the age are false and baseless. On the contrary, one can see how Allah the Almighty fulfilled His promises given to the Promised Messiah^(as) about his victory and the victory of his Community. The second half of the book provides a refutation to the allegations leveled by the author of the pamphlet Fateh-e-Qadian against the Promised Messiah^(as). Issues such as the status of Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad^(as), his respect for other Prophets, his extreme love and devotion for the Seal of Prophets, the Holy Prophet Muhammad (may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) and arguments for the natural death of Jesus [Hazrat Isa^(as)] are discussed. Moreover, arguments in support of the truth of the Promised Messiah^(as) are also discussed.