A Critical Review of the Pamphlet, 'Fateh-e-Qadian' — Page 7
i‘j a zul-Ma si h —A Miracle of the Promised Messiah as 7 [ Hadrat ‘ I s a as ] was alive, using the same ‘arguments’ as Maulav i Muhammad Gh a z i did. Yet, the fact totally escaped the P i r that just as a weak rope cannot give support to anything, a weak argument does not help anyone either. Hence, the logical and historically accurate arguments presented by the Promised Messiah, Hadrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad as on the death of Jesus [ Hadrat ‘ I s a as ] stood tall and firm, like an unscaled mountain. Hadrat Syed Muhammad A h san of Amroha, a companion of Hadrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, wrote an excellent book to rebut Shamsul- H id a yah. —the book published in the name of P i r [Meher ‘Al i ]. He entitled his book Shams-e-B a zighah 5. Through the publication of this book, he not only proved the absolute hollowness of the P i r’s arguments but also manifested how degraded were the views held by the P i r. Indeed, the arguments presented in this book serve to cause shame for the followers of the P i r even to this age. On the last page of Shamsul-Hid a yah, the real author of the book, Maulav i Muhammad Gh a z i , had invited the Promised Messiah, Hadrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad as to a debate ‘subject to satisfactory arrangements’. Syed Muhammad A h san of Amroha informed the P i r in an announcement made on the July 9, 1900, that he was ready for the debate. He invited the P i r stating: You should announce your readiness otherwise it will prove that the truth is on our side. ( al- H akam , July 9, 1900, pp. 10–11 and July 23, 1900, p. 5, col. 3) 5 Meaning: The Rising Sun [Publishers]