Christianity - A Journey from Facts to Fiction

by Hazrat Mirza Tahir Ahmad

Page 49 of 211

Christianity - A Journey from Facts to Fiction — Page 49

Sin and Atonement 49 Atonement was based on anything which Jesus as might have said or done or taught. He could never have preached anything so contrary, and so diametrically opposed, to human intellect. Did God the Father Suffer as Well? Coming to the nature of the ‘Son’, we cannot believe that he was thrown into Hell Fire, as that would mean an internal contradic- tion with himself. Returning to the basic concept of Christianity we see that it is said that God and the ‘Son’ are two persons but of the same nature and substance. It is impossible for one to go through an experience while the other does not share in it. How can we believe that one aspect of God, the ‘Son’, was being tormented, while God the Father remained unscathed? If He did not suffer, it would be tantamount to breaking the Unity of God. Three persons in one becomes even more inconceivable because the experiences of each constituent of Trinity have turned out to be so different and remote from each other that it appears impos- sible for one God to be in the raging fire of hell, and at the same time the other to remain perfectly aloof and untouched. There is no other choice for the Christians of today but either to sacrifice the Unity of God and believe in three different Gods, like the pagans of pre-Christianity such as the Romans and the Greeks, or to remain true to themselves and believe that God is one and as such, two aspects of God cannot undergo contradictory states. When a child suffers, it is impossible for the mother to remain calm and peaceful. She must suffer as well, sometimes more than the child. What was happening to God the Father when He made