Three in One — Page 335
the author of Two in One allege would be fulfilled literally. . Nonetheless, Abdul Hafeez states that Hadhrat Ahmadas declared that the sun will not rise from the west⁹ - suggesting that Hadhrat Ahmadas denied the authenticity of the Hadeeth. . This, once again, is a blatant lie since Hadhrat Ahmad as stated quite clearly that 'he held faith on the authenticity of the. Hadeeth in relation to the rising of the sun from the west. 192. Although, on the basis of a vision, he interpreted this to mean that the west would be enlightened to the truth of Islam,. Hadhrat Ahmad as also declared that he does not deny that it could also have some other meaning '93 - suggesting that if God. Almighty so decreed that the sun should physically rise of the west, then it is in his power to do so. 22. Abdul Hafeez then accuses Hadhrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmadas for having stated that 'there is no punishment in the grave 194 which is yet another blatant lie uttered by the author of Two in. One. What he argued against was the literal torment of the dead in their graves by scorpions and snakes since what is stated on the basis of a vision or a dream is subject to interpretation. " As regards punishment in the grave, Hadhrat Ahmad as stated that 'for the dead body of a person, a window is opened in the grave towards hell through which a consuming vapour arrives in the grave from hell and that wicked soul burns all the time in its flames. 1% 23. It is then alleged that Hadhrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmadas claimed that 'tanasikh [transmigration of souls is correct '97 which is a sly misrepresentation of his discussion on this concept. If. Abdul Hafeez must know, Hadhrat Ahmadas considered the 91. Shah, Syed Abdul Hafeez. Two in One, p. 52 92. Ahmad, [Hadhrat] Mirza Ghulam. Izalah Auham, p. 515; Ruhani Khazain, vol. 3, p. 376 93. Ahmad, [Hadhrat] Mirza Ghulam. Izalah Auham, pp. 515/16; Ruhani Khazain, vol. 3, p. 376 94. Shah, Syed Abdul Hafeez. Two in One, p. 52 95. Ahmad, [Hadhrat] Mirza Ghulam. Izalah Auham, p. 415; Ruhani Khazain, vol. 3, p. 316. 96. Ahmad, [Hadhrat] Mirza Ghulam. Izalah Auham, p. 358; Ruhani Khazain, vol. 3, p. 283 97. Shah, Syed Abdul Hafeez. Two in One, p. 52 335