The System of Mushawarat in Jama'at-e-Ahmadiyya — Page 312
the S ystem of M ushawarat in J ama ‘ at - e -A hmadiyya proposal w ill be rejected. The proposal o f the sub committee and the first proposal w ill also go overboard. That is where we stand in this situation. So now I call for division. Those who are in favour o f accepting the pro posal o f the sub-com m ittee. . . because Hidayatullah Hubsh has very rightly pointed out that the reasoning is not all correct, so forget about the reasoning part, those who agree with the proposal o f the sub-committee should raise their hands. There is only one hand which is not raised, which I can not see, but that does not matter anymore, because all the members here have raised their hands in favour o f the sub-committee’s amended proposal. So that becomes the recommendation, and I accept that recommendation. ” [Report International Majlis-e-Shura 1991, p. 38] (vii) Hudur mentioned the procedure to be followed when a member o f a sub-committee differs from the rec ommendations o f the sub-committee. He said: [English] “So this becomes a Tarmlm (amendment). As such an amendment should have been suggested in writ ing to the committee o f which you were a member. ” Speaker: “It was presented, Sir, but it was rejected. ” Hudur: “And yet you registered your right to speak in fa vour o f the rejected amendment. ” Speaker: “Y es, sir. ” Hudur: “That cannot be done. You see, you have the right o f dissent and you have the right to speak against the deci sion o f the committee o f which you are a member, that is very clear. But an amendment, when it is brought, is not discussed, but any other member here has a right to pro 312