A Review of the Debate between Batalavi and Chakrhalavi

by Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad

Page 21 of 37

A Review of the Debate between Batalavi and Chakrhalavi — Page 21

‘Abdull « a »h denigration of hadith 11 Ab « u » Bakr, « H »a « d »rat burned questionable a « h » ad « i »th on account of his fear of God 8 Ahl-e- « H »ad « i »th extreme position in emphasiz- ing hadith over Quran 3 Bat « a »lw « i », Mu « h »ammad « H »usain views on hadith 1 , 3 Chakrh « a »lv i », ‘Abdull « a »h inventing new form of « s »al« a »t 2 preposterous views of, 11 rejection of hadith by, 4 Conjecture Quran on comparison of certainty with, 5 Criteria for judging hadith 10 Fatherhood of Holy Prophet 13 Finality of Holy Prophet 12 God love of, linked to following Holy Prophet 4 Hadith ‘Abdull « a »h Chakrh « a »lvi »’s rejec- tion of, 4 compilation of, 5 8 criteria for judging 10 difference between sunnah and, 7 majority of compilers were God-fearing rejection of, tantamount to rejection of Quran 4 scholars ascribing authority over Quran 4 served only to enhance light of Islam 9 sheds light on Quran 1 subservient to Quran 5 third means for muslims to establish themselves on Islam 7 what is meant by, 7 Index