The Holy War — Page 145
Proceedings—Debate 29 May 1893 145 difficult matter at all, but to remove the obstinacy of the heart is a feat for God. Then, in your lecture, you claimed that the marvels are with Islam. We have no objection to seeing them. But supposing one or more marvels are indeed wrought, do also tell us how we would know that they are from Allah? You yourself have cited (Deuteronomy 13:1, 2) that false prophets will arise to test you and show miracles and Signs. You can also see Mark 13:22 and Galatians 1:8. Therefore, my dear Sir, the need is not only of marvels but how to be convinced that they are from Allah. And I submit to you with great respect that I am heartbroken with your marvels. You have yourself stated that there is a difference between a Sign and a mira- cle, but what that is, I do not know. Then you stated that you do not know what sort of Sign He will show. And then that you do not know what manner of Sign He will show. Sir! In this there is a clear attempt at evasion from showing any miracle and marvels, whereas you had already agreed to this in your paper H ujjatul-Isl a m , p. 14–17. In short, what a blessed occasion this was for you to establish the claim that you had been so vehemently making for so many days. A thousand pities that you let such a good opportunity pass through your hands and avoided the issue with your absurd inter- pretations and meaningless accusatory replies. By your avoidance, this humble one’s simple mind understands that this claim of yours is all by way of you trying to make your followers happy. By way of kindness, please do not mention these claims in front of Christians again because it would be needless humiliation. Sir, we had heard so much of your scholarship and broad-mind- edness, and we had great hopes from you. It is a pity that you pre- sented the same old contentions and arguments and statements that have been making the rounds in this country’s bazaars for the last forty years.