A Critical Review of the Pamphlet, 'Fateh-e-Qadian'

by Hadi Ali Chaudhary

Page 57 of 171

A Critical Review of the Pamphlet, 'Fateh-e-Qadian' — Page 57

The Promised Messiah as did not bring a new law 57 commentary of the Holy Quran, Tafs i r-e-Bai da v i , that they used to write. Whether the Promised Messiah as becomes the target of his attack or not, the above Prophets are certainly becoming its target. If you look at the above mentioned text of Musht a q Chisht i from another angle, it points to a clear deception. About the Prophets he writes: They bring a book and call people to the book which has been sent. They do not write a book. ( F a te h -e-Qadian, p. 11) If one reflects a little, he will realise that the books which the Prophets bring, or the books which they ask people to follow, are of a different kind altogether. They are called Divine Books and contain the Shar i ‘ah law. It is an audacity to link the books of the Promised Messiah as with them, and then to compare them with the Divine Books is an affront. Never did the Promised Messiah as claim that any of his books is a book of Shar i ‘ah. Each of his books is comprised of commentary and elucidation of the Shar i ‘ah of Holy Prophet Muhammad sa. As for instance, the book I‘j a zul-Mas ih comprises a narration of the truth and wisdom contained in S u rah al-F a ti h ah. Therefore, it is inconceivable to imagine any book of the Promised Messiah as to be akin to a Divine Book or like the Books of Shar i ‘ah which the Prophets bring or teach.